What Eithan Haim’s Victory Teaches Us
This article was originally published by The Christian Post.
By Bunni Pounds
The recent dismissal of the Department of Justice case against Dr. Eithan Haim is not just a legal victory for one person, but a crucial moment in the fight to protect children from harm. It is also another example of the real fact that if we, as American citizens, speak up loudly and consistency against injustices and pray, vote, and engage — electing leaders who are pursuing justice — that we can see victories on the issues that we care about.
The 34-year-old surgeon, who bravely exposed Texas Children's Hospital (TCH) for continuing transgender procedures on minors despite publicly stating otherwise, should never have been prosecuted in the first place. His case was a blatant attempt to punish a whistleblower for revealing the truth, and its dismissal is a confirmation of justice, accountability, and the right to expose wrongdoing.
“WE DID IT!!!! WE WON!!!!!!!” Dr. Haim’s post celebrated following the announcement dismissing the case was released.
As one of the leaders of the social conservative movement, we, at Family Policy Alliance, highlighted Dr. Haim’s story and his case at our SoConCon event last summer in front of top organization and ministry leaders. Our family policy councils around the nation, especially Texas Values in Dr. Haim’s home state, highlighted his story non-stop as we also worked together to push back against gender modification surgeries with our initiative Help, not Harm that we launched in 2021.
Let’s go back in time on the importance of this story. Dr. Haim’s decision to leak documents to journalist Christopher Rufo was not a reckless act of defiance but a moral imperative. The documents revealed that TCH was secretly performing transgender procedures on minors, a practice that contradicted its public statements. His revelations had immediate consequences: within 24 hours of Rufo’s reporting, the Texas Legislature passed SB-14, officially outlawing these procedures for minors.
Yet instead of being recognized for his bravery, Haim was met with multiple felony charges that could have resulted in a decade-long prison sentence and a $250,000 fine. His alleged crime? Exposing a major hospital’s deception and ensuring that laws designed to protect children were enforced. The irony is striking; while those responsible for these procedures faced no legal consequences, the man who brought their actions to light was the one facing prison time.
The timing and nature of the charges against Dr. Haim suggested that his prosecution was politically motivated. The Department of Justice (DOJ) under the Biden administration aggressively pursued his case, even though his disclosures directly aligned with the newly enacted Texas law.
The case took an ever more serious turn when, on the night of Haim’s surgical residency graduation, agents from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) arrived unannounced at his doorstep, informing him that he was a “potential target” in a criminal investigation. Such intimidation tactics are more reminiscent of authoritarian regimes than of a country that prides itself on due process and the rule of law.
“I am scheduled to go to trial in a few weeks in a place which has up until this point been nothing less than a kangaroo court. All of the most basic rules have been violated in favor of a corrupted DOJ and all of it has come at the cost of my constitutional rights,” Haim wrote in a statement ahead of his scheduled trial in January.
The situation has dramatically changed. Following President Donald Trump’s executive order to end the political weaponization of the federal government, U.S. District Court Judge David Hittner dismissed the case with prejudice, ensuring that Haim cannot be charged again on these grounds.
This dismissal sends a powerful message. The Haim case was about more than just one doctor — it was about the broader principles of free speech and medical ethics, in direct opposition to the perniciousness of so-called gender ideology.
If he had been convicted, it would have set a dangerous precedent, discouraging other medical professionals from speaking out against dangerous transgender procedures conducted against children. Fear of prosecution could have deterred whistleblowers from reporting malpractice, effectively allowing hospitals and other medical institutions to operate without accountability.
TCH’s actions — publicly denying that it was performing these procedures while secretly continuing them — should concern everyone. If a major pediatric hospital is willing to mislead the public on an issue as serious as this, what else might it be hiding?
While the dismissal of Haim’s case is a victory, it is not the end of the fight for accountability. His wife, Andrea Haim, made it clear that those responsible for harming children and misleading the public must face consequences. The focus should now shift to Texas Children’s Hospital and other institutions engaging in similar deceptive practices.
Dr. Haim’s story serves as a powerful reminder of what true courage looks like. He was not a powerful politician or a wealthy corporate executive, he was a young surgeon who saw something wrong and refused to stay silent. When faced with the choice between his own safety and protecting vulnerable children, he stood for what was right. His actions exemplify the highest ideals of medical ethics and moral integrity.
The dismissal of his case is a win for children — and for whistleblowers, justice, and the truth. But as we celebrate this victory, we must remain vigilant. This victory story only happened because people around this nation like you and I stood up and spoke up against injustices. The fight to protect our children is far from over.
CHRISTIANS ENGAGED NEEDS YOU!
Would you consider partnering with us as a monthly donor to support the work of our nonprofit ministry? Or maybe a generous one-time donation?